The recently released Coaches Poll top 25 ignited discussions about the merits of preseason rankings. Critics often argue these lists create unjust disparities among teams based on their perceived value before the start of the season.

Coaches have noted that quickly changing rosters make it challenging to accurately gauge the best teams. Recently, some conferences have opted out of formal preseason media polls, stating they wish to avoid biases affecting final rankings.

With this shift, Kansas State’s coach Chris Klieman emphasized to CBS Sports, “When the CFP comes out, that’s when the first AP and USA Today poll should come out. The narrative tells you everything, and unfortunately, that’s not great for the Big 12. It’s probably not great for the ACC. You know, it’s just not.”

Understanding the Impact of Rankings

While the argument against preseason polls holds merit, it is incomplete. Despite their flaws, these rankings are crucial for generating excitement in the sport.

For example, Kansas State will kick off their season against Iowa State in Dublin, a game crucial for both teams within the Big 12 and the College Football Playoff framework. It’s currently a highly-rated matchup as per the Coaches Poll.

In contrast, the matchup between Alabama and Florida State, despite their historical significance, lacks the same appeal due to the inconsistency of both teams.

Klieman’s points suggest that rankings serve a purpose in marketing and promoting college football. Eliminating them may further bolster the narratives surrounding powerhouse programs, acting as a disservice to lesser-known teams.

Conclusion: Preseason polls, despite generating some controversy, stimulate crucial discussions and storytelling in college football, creating a vibrant competitive atmosphere that fans enjoy.