The Indiana Fever announced that veteran guard Sophie Cunningham will be sidelined for the rest of the season due to a knee injury she incurred during a crucial comeback win against the Connecticut Sun. Reports indicate she tore her MCL. This injury marks the third such occurrence for the Fever this month as fellow guards Aari McDonald and Sydney Colson are also facing season-ending injuries. Additionally, star guard Caitlin Clark has been out with a groin injury and does not yet have a return date.

With only weeks left in the regular season, the Fever are currently positioned sixth but face a challenging schedule ahead. They entered the season with high hopes but now must determine whether to continue pushing for a playoff spot or to plan for the future.

Making the playoffs

Pro: Give yourself a chance
The absence of Cunningham, who was a key 3-point shooter, poses a significant challenge. Still, should Caitlin Clark return to health for the playoffs, the team remains a contender.

Con: Likely poorer draft pick
If the Fever reach the playoffs, they may miss out on a higher draft pick in the upcoming draft class, which includes talented prospects.

Pro: More experience for the core
Securing another playoff appearance could be valuable for the Fever’s young roster, having only made the playoffs once in recent years.

Con: Risk of further injury for Clark
Given Clark’s injury history this season, rushing her back could lead to further complications.

Lottery trip

Pro: Chance at the No. 1 pick
Even with limited odds, making the lottery could bring new talent to the Fever’s ranks.

Con: A wasted season
Failing to make the playoffs after investing heavily this offseason would be seen as a failure.

The decision that the Fever face—whether to strive for playoffs or aim for the future—could define the direction of the franchise for years to come.