The coaching carousel is moving faster than ever, which requires coaches to adapt quickly as they take on new roles. After two years, various coaches from the 2023-24 cycle have already made their marks as either successes or failures.

The highlight among these coaches is Curt Cignetti, the head coach for Indiana, who is being hailed for his remarkable achievement of leading the Hoosiers to a national championship. Alongside him, six other coaches have reached the College Football Playoff during their initial years in charge, with Manny Diaz of Duke also securing an ACC title.

Conversely, the pressure has led to the dismissal of four other coaches, namely Trent Bray (Oregon State), Jonathan Smith (Michigan State), DeShaun Foster (UCLA), and Sherrone Moore (Michigan). As Year 3 approaches, more coaches may face similar fates.

A detailed grading of every second-year coach in college football after the 2025 season includes various ratings, reflecting their performance and potential. Here is the summary:

Team	Coach	Record	Analysis	Grade
Alabama	Kalen DeBoer	20-8	Significant steps forward but still needs to redefine identity.	C+
Indiana	Curt Cignetti	27-2	Outstanding achievement leading to a national title.	A+++
Duke	Manny Diaz	18-9	Secured an ACC title amidst ups and downs.	B+
Michigan	Sherrone Moore	16-8	Fired due to controversy and off-field issues.	F