Summary

It is always uncertain how a pitcher will perform after returning from Tommy John surgery, particularly when making their comeback. A good example of this is Sandy Alcantara, whose first season back in 2025 has been challenging.

When assessing pitchers recovering from elbow surgery, cautious optimism is advisable. We should remain receptive to their potential return to form, yet it’s essential to confirm their readiness before adding them to our fantasy rosters. This week featured two notable pitchers returning to action post-surgery, and both could quickly become prized assets in fantasy leagues.

Highlights from Their Returns

1. Tony Gonsolin, SP, Dodgers (47%) - Gonsolin faced the Marlins in his season debut, impressively striking out nine in six innings while giving up just three earned runs, despite a subpar performance from his defense. His average exit velocity of 83.4 mph on 15 batted balls demonstrates promising control and effectiveness.

2. Lucas Giolito, SP, Red Sox (43%) - Giolito showcased competence in his first game back, yielding three runs and achieving seven strikeouts against the Blue Jays. His fastball maintained velocity close to pre-injury levels, yielding solid results.

Both pitchers displayed substantial upside, fine additions to fantasy rosters if you’re looking for quality starters.

Additional Waiver Wire Targets

• Kevin Ginkel, RP, Diamondbacks (5%) – With concerns about Justin Martinez’s health, Ginkel may soon emerge as the likely closer. Ginkel’s season debut was promising, but expectations on his role remain tentative.
• Masyn Winn, SS, Cardinals (56%) – After a shaky start, Winn’s recent performance suggests he may be on the verge of a breakout.
• Noah Cameron, SP, Royals (6%) – Cameron’s debut was solid, but concerns linger regarding his command and sustainability.
• Chris Martin, RP, Rangers (28%) – Despite his past performances, Martin remains underutilized, yet he may soon play a key role in the Rangers’ bullpen.