Debating NFL quarterbacks is an ongoing and complex discussion. Quarterbacks are pivotal in a team’s success, carrying the weight of their performance both for credit and criticism. The rankings derived from statistics can provide insights, but categorizing quarterbacks into tiers often offers more context.
Tier 1: Transcendent Talents (6)
These quarterbacks exemplify what teams aspire to have. They possess unrivaled skills and proven excellence in critical scenarios. With moderate support, they can lead teams to significant victories.
-
Patrick Mahomes (KC • QB • Age: 29 | Season: 9th) Mahomes is a standout quarterback, essential for the Chiefs’ success. Despite setbacks in the recent Super Bowl, his ability to lead remains unmatched.
-
Josh Allen (BUF • QB • Age: 29 | Season: 8th) Allen consistently performs at a high level and is a robust threat on the field.
-
Lamar Jackson (BAL • QB • Age: 28 | Season: 8th) The dynamic potential of Jackson puts him consistently in the elite discussion, with impressive statistics backing his play.
-
Joe Burrow (CIN • QB • Age: 28 | Season: 6th) Burrow’s exceptional passing skills make him one of the most efficient quarterbacks in the league.
-
Jalen Hurts (PHI • QB • Age: 26 | Season: 6th) Hurts knows how to get results, whether in the air or on the ground.
-
Jayden Daniels (WAS • QB • Age: 24 | Season: 2nd) As a new face with immense promise, Daniels has set high expectations with a stellar debut.
Tier 2: Borderline Stars (8)
These quarterbacks may not always shine as brightly as the top tier but can lead their teams successfully under the right circumstances.
- Matthew Stafford (LAR • QB • Age: 37 | Season: 17th)
- Jared Goff (DET • QB • Age: 30 | Season: 10th)
- Brock Purdy (SF • QB • Age: 25 | Season: 4th)
- Jordan Love (GB • QB • Age: 26 | Season: 6th)
- Justin Herbert (LAC • QB • Age: 27 | Season: 6th)
- Dak Prescott (DAL • QB • Age: 31 | Season: 10th)
- Baker Mayfield (TB • QB • Age: 30 | Season: 8th)
- C.J. Stroud (HOU • QB • Age: 23 | Season: 3rd)
Tier 3: Promising Prospects (4)
Focus on the emerging quarterbacks ready to take their teams to the next level.
- Bo Nix (DEN • QB • Age: 25 | Season: 2nd)
- Caleb Williams (CHI • QB • Age: 23 | Season: 2nd)
- J.J. McCarthy (MIN • QB • Age: 22 | Season: 2nd)
- Drake Maye (NE • QB • Age: 22 | Season: 2nd)
Tier 4: Volatile Veterans (6)
This tier houses unpredictable talents who can fluctuate between game-changing performances and disappointing outings.
- Aaron Rodgers (PIT • QB • Age: 41 | Season: 21st)
- Geno Smith (LV • QB • Age: 34 | Season: 13th)
- Trevor Lawrence (JAC • QB • Age: 25 | Season: 5th)
- Tua Tagovailoa (MIA • QB • Age: 27 | Season: 6th)
- Kyler Murray (ARI • QB • Age: 27 | Season: 7th)
- Sam Darnold (SEA • QB • Age: 28 | Season: 8th)
Tier 5: Prized Project (1)
Focusing on the fresh talent primed for a breakout year.
- Cam Ward (TEN • QB • Age: 23 | Season: 1st)
Tier 6: Holdovers and Placeholders (7)
These players might be placeholder quarterbacks, hoping to remain relevant as newer players rise.
- Justin Fields (NYJ • QB • Age: 26 | Season: 5th)
- Russell Wilson (NYG • QB • Age: 36 | Season: 14th)
- Bryce Young (CAR • QB • Age: 23 | Season: 3rd)
- Michael Penix Jr. (ATL • QB • Age: 25 | Season: 2nd)
- Joe Flacco (CLE • QB • Age: 40 | Season: 18th)
- Anthony Richardson (IND • QB • Age: 23 | Season: 3rd)
- Tyler Shough (NO • QB • Age: 25 | Season: 1st)
This summary offers a structured perspective on the current quarterback landscape as we look forward to the 2025 NFL season.
