Over the past quarter-century, the NFL has evolved into a league primarily centered around quarterbacks, marked by shifts in play style, individual accolades, and player compensation. In fact, every NFL MVP award given in the last twelve years has gone to quarterbacks, who also command the highest salaries.

Tom Brady stands as a pivotal figure in this historical shift; he has claimed a record-breaking seven Super Bowl victories, along with five Super Bowl MVP awards and three league MVP titles.
While Brady shines as an example of quarterback excellence, Patrick Mahomes is also carving out an impressive legacy. Mahomes, who took over the mantle from Brady, is on track to become an all-time great, poised for Hall of Fame recognition even if he were to retire today.
How does Mahomes fit into a lineup of football’s 25 finest players? Here are the criteria used for our rankings:

• Individual success and accolades
• Dominance in their era
• Longevity and career milestones
• Lasting impact and legacy
• Team achievements and championships
• Performance relative to their position

Here’s a peek at the top players, beginning with honorable mentions:

• Emlen Tunnell, DB (1948-1961): The first Black player inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, Tunnell was instrumental in the Giants’ 1956 championship.
• Don Hutson, WR (1935-1945): The first prolific wideout in the NFL who retired with 99 career touchdowns.
• Tony Gonzalez, TE (1997-2013): The most consistent tight end in NFL history and a perennial Pro Bowl selection.
• Gale Sayers, RB (1965-1971): Noted for his electrifying playing style, he’s remembered as one of the game’s greatest running backs.
• Rod Woodson, DB (1987-2003): A versatile defender known for his outstanding athletic performance and leadership.

Join the conversation about these players and their legacy in the changing landscape of the NFL.