
Welcome to NFL Thoughts
A comprehensive look at significant narratives from the 2025 season. Previously, topics ranged from the Chiefs’ quest for a third consecutive Super Bowl to the performance of top running backs in new teams. This year, we kick off with a focus on the intriguing quarterbacks from the notable 2024 rookie class.
Caleb Williams: Addressing Critical Play Issues
Caleb Williams, drafted first overall by the Chicago Bears, had a tumultuous first season. Despite showing flashes of talent, he faced significant challenges in 2024, particularly with a high sack rate leading to diminished expected points added (EPA).
Quote from Bears Coach Ben Johnson:
“The EPA [expected points added] in the passing game is really one of the most critical factors…”
Johnson aims to improve Williams’s performance by enhancing offensive line protection and coaching strategies. Williams must adapt to his new environment and play decisively to fulfill his potential.
Jayden Daniels: Building on a Stellar Rookie Year
Jayden Daniels, drafted second by the Washington Commanders, is coming off one of the most remarkable rookie seasons. His calm demeanor and adept processing of defensive strategies set a precedent. However, there’s room for improvement, particularly regarding accuracy when pressured.
Daniels’s ability to scramble and extend plays significantly contributed to his success, but he must refine his pocket accuracy for continued growth.
Drake Maye: Overcoming Early Struggles
Drake Maye of the New England Patriots navigated a challenging rookie season but displayed promising growth. With new weapons and enhanced support on the offensive line, Maye’s ability to learn from mistakes could allow him to emerge as a key contributor.
Michael Penix Jr. and J.J. McCarthy: Potential in Uncertainty
Michael Penix Jr. managed to shine despite limited playing time, while J.J. McCarthy’s transition to the Minnesota Vikings will depend on his adjustment to the NFL pace and the effectiveness of play-action strategies.
Bo Nix: An Emerging Star
Bo Nix surprised many with solid performances in Denver, showcasing his potential through efficient play-calling and execution.
In 2025, this rookie class has potential beyond expectations, each quarterback poised to make an impact as they mature into their roles.